CRITICAL READING TASK (Review Journal)

Review Journal

Review Journal with the topic Strategy approach to English education

The Component of Journal

Title :

The Strategies of Indonesian Junior High School Students in Learning Listening Skill 

Journal : 

Arab World English Journal (AWEJ) 

Volume and page :

Vol. 7, No 4, December 2016, Page 117-124

Publicated year :

2016

Writer :

1) Alfan Zuhairi 

2) Ika Hidayanti

Reviewer :

Dhea Fitri Ayuningtyas (2010631060066)

Date :

April, 17th 2022

The aim of research :

The aim of this research is to identifying the intensity of strategies use in learning listening, investigating the inter-correlation among the strategies deployment, and describing how significantly successful and less successful learners differ in the use of strategies. 

The subject of research :

Two hundred and fifty seven students at seventh and eighth grade of junior high school in Malang. 

The assesment data :

50 items strategies questionnaire of learning listening taken from Oxford strategy taxonomy. 

Methodology of research :

The current study applied descriptive and causal –comparative designs. The former design was to find the answer for questions 1 and 2 on the frequency use of the strategies and the inter-correlation among strategy category. 

Discussion :

In terms of correlation, the statistical result shows that some of the strategies employed correlate significantly but some of them do not correlate each other. This reveals that six correlation coefficients correlate positively and significantly at .01 level (2-tailed) and one correlation coefficient does not correlate significantly at .05 level. In other side, some coefficients correlate significantly and positively for some strategies deployment. This positive correlation means that the increase frequency of use of certain strategy tend to influence to an increase use of other strategies of learning listening skill.  The finding also shows that there is no significant difference in the use of learning strategy in learning listening skill by less successful learners accounted for higher mean than the successful learners. This finding implies that successful learners deploy the strategies in learning listening not significantly different from the less successful learners. 

Conclusion

The present study revealed with the findings on the intensity of strategies use, the correlation among the use and the significant difference between successful and less successful learners. The first result on the investigation of the intensity indicated that the overall strategies employment were at moderate level. The compensation strategies were most intensively used, in opposite, the social strategies were least intensively taken by the students. Then the finding on the interrelationship among the strategies deployment indicated that some of the strategies had significant and positive correlation and some of them were not correlated. Meanwhile, the statistical result on the difference of the strategies showed that the strategies use was not significantly different between high achievers and low achievers. Both groups confirmed the use of cognitive strategies at highest mean difference, and social strategies were at the lowest mean difference. In relation to some previous studies, the overall use of learning strategies confirms the same result. It implies that the strategies provide positive effect on the students listening comprehension and proficiency although both groups of learners performed similar result on strategy attainment.  

The advantages of research in this journal

The strategies provide positive effect on the students listening comprehension and proficiency although both groups of learners performed similar result on strategy attainment.   

Disadvantages of research in this journal

There has been no implementation of strategies such as social strategies that ultimately contribute to the development of listening skills.

Journal Source :

https://doi.org/10.24093/awej/vol7no4.8

Reference of journal

Zuhairi, A., & Hidayanti, I. (2016). The strategies of Indonesian junior high school students in learning listening skill. Arab World English Journal (AWEJ), 7(4).

CRITICAL READING TASK (Review Journal)

Review Journal

Review Journal with the topic Strategy approach to English education

The Component of Journal

Title :

WHAT IS YOUR FAVORITE MOVIE?: A STRATEGY OF ENGLISH EDUCATION STUDENTS TO IMPROVE ENGLISH VOCABULARY 

Journal : 

Journal of English Language Teaching and Learning

Volume and page :

Vol. 1, No 2, December 2020, Page 44-49

Publicated year :

2020

Writer :

1) Marta Widiawitasari Br Simamora

2) Lulud Oktaviani

Reviewer :

Dhea Fitri Ayuningtyas (2010631060066) 

Date :

11 April 2022

The aim of research :

The aim of this research is to know is watching students' favorite movie can increase student skill of English vocabulary. 

The subject of research :

students from the English Education Study Program of Faculty of Arts and Education in Universitas Teknokrat Indonesia. 

The assesment data :

Descriptive qualitative, questionnaires and interviews

Methodology of research :

In this study, a descriptive qualitative method was employed. This research was done through questionnaires and interviews. In the questionnaire, researchers provided 5 questions to students that were distributed to the participants to collect their perspective data. After the researchers distributed the questionnaire, the researchers also continued with an interview. 

Discussion :

The questionnaire consisted of two types of questions. There were yes-no questions and scale questions. 

The first question is "Do you like watching English movies?". Of 27 people who filled out the questionnaire, 99.3% of them liked watching English movies while 6,7% of them don’t like to watch movies. It showed that almost all of the participants had a positive thought about watching English Movies. The second question is How often do you watch English Movies? By seeing the diagram at this journal, it could be stated that only 4% of the participants were very rare in watching a movie while 44% of them were often watching a movie and 22% of them were frequently watching English movies. Then, it could be concluded that almost all of the participants were often watching English movies. The next question is Do you think watching English movies could help you learn English?. The data showed that all the participants (100%) agreed that while watching English movies, they could also learn English. This proof that by watching movies, students could gain new knowledge about the English Language. The fourth question is “Do you think watching English Movies could increase your vocabulary?. The result was the same as the previous question that all participants agreed by watching English Movies they could gain new vocabulary. This data showed that through watching English movies, students learned new words that they did not learn in school/college. The last question for the yes/no question is "Do you think watching English Movie Improve your listening ability?". As stated before that watching movies also could help students in improving their listening ability, and by listening and watching the movies students will found new English words. The data in this journal showed that 89% of the participants believed that by watching English movies they could improve their listening skills while 11 % of them disagreed with this statement. The result of this research also showed that through watching movies students not only could gain more vocabulary but also could improve other skills like Listening Skills. 

Conclusion

From all data above, researchers concluded that watching English Movies could help students in learning English. This could happen because in watching movies students often hearing new words that they might never hear before. They could also guess the meaning through the sentence, expression, and scene in the movies. The participants also said that the more they watched English movies, the more they got influence by the English Movies. The influence here is the way the actors or actresses speak and use them in sentences. Watching English movies also made the students accustomed to the English language. They also have added some vocabularies to their memory through listening and watching English Movies. 

The advantages of research in this journal

The advantage of this journal is that it uses a qualitative descriptive research method, namely questionnaires and interviews. Here, it is very visible that the participation of the subject under study on whether watching a favorite movie can improve students' English vocabulary skills. Here it is clearly seen through the diagrammatic photos of the results of the research which show that the participants agreed to the questions posed by the author. In my opinion, the structure of this journal is complete, from the purpose to the conclusion the author presents it very neatly. This makes it easy for readers to understand the contents of this journal.

Disadvantages of research in this journal

The shortcomings encountered by the authors The title does not state for what school level this research was carried out. 

Journal Source :

https://doi.org/10.33365/jeltl.v1i2.604

Reference of journal

Simamora, M. W. B., & Oktaviani, L. (2020). What is your favorite movie?: a strategy of English Education students to improve english vocabulary. Journal of English Language Teaching and Learning, 1(2), 44-49.

CRITICAL READING TASK (Review Journal)

Review Journal

Review Journal with the topic Strategy approach to English education

The Component of Journal

Title :

English Learning Strategies among EFL Learners: A Narrative Approach 

Journal : 

Journal of Language Learning 

Volume and page :

Vol. 3 Number 1, 2017, Page 4-19

Publicated year :

2017

Writer :

1) Hoang Nguyen 

2) Daniel R. Terry 

Reviewer :

Dhea Fitri Ayuningtyas (2010631060066)

Date :

24 Maret 2022

The aim of research :

The goal of this study is a textual and interpretative nature with emerging themes and issues related to the attitudes towards and actual use of LLSs among the target learners. The findings provide practical implications for practitioners, researchers and educational policy makers alike.  

The subject of research :

10 English as a foreign language (EFL), teaching staff, including 3 males and 7 females, were between 26 and 50 years of age and their teaching experience ranged from 2 to 20 years at tertiary level. The sampled students were also chosen to reflect the diversity of backgrounds in terms of gender (3 males, 7 females)

The assesment data :

The interview questions for students focussed on their general attitudes and lived experiences of LLSs.

Methodology of research :

This study utilized the conceptual framework of socio-cultural theory, in that learning is a social process where the development of cognition occurs through the interaction with others in a society and also influenced by the culture where an individual is situated. 

Discussion :

attribution of success in learning English to several elements, which is a positive perception. This debunks the myth of the absolute power of every single factor in language learning. This has major implications for the teaching profession, that the improvement of LLS needs to go hand in hand with other important tasks, such as stimulation of interest in learning, strengthening of learning determination, and encouragement of learning efforts on the part of teachers.

Conclusion

the need to move forward in language learning strategies that promote students' ability to find what works for them, to overcome or discard old strategies and be flexible in trying new and unfamiliar strategies. Language teaching then moves beyond language learning and related strategies, motivating students to learn skills and to equip students to develop positive strategies that can be used outside higher education and enhance language development as a lifelong process.

The advantages of research in this journal

The advantages presented by the authors in this journal are can make teachers be open to other strategies that have been proven successful or developed by students themselves. This may include the use of technology and personal interests that encourage a desire to learn and develop language acquisition outside of the classroom. Language teaching then moves beyond language learning and related strategies, motivating students to learn skills and to equip students to develop positive strategies that can be used outside of higher education and enhance language development as a lifelong process.

Disadvantages of research in this journal

The shortcomings encountered by the authors in the research is Language learning strategies, particularly in tertiary environments, have moved beyond rote learning, grammar exercises and primary and secondary school approaches to language development. Language learning strategies and processes at the college level today also depend on many factors such as individual talent, perseverance, hard work, and positive attitudes of teachers and students.

Journal Source :

https://eric.ed.gov/?id=EJ1167252

Reference of journal

Nguyen, H., & Terry, D. R. (2017). English Learning Strategies among EFL Learners: A Narrative Approach. IAFOR Journal of Language Learning, 3(1), 4-19.

Critical Reading Task (Review Journal)

Review Journal

Review Journal with the topic of speaking comprehension

The Component of Journal

Title :

THE IMPLEMENTATION CLT APPROACH TO IMPROVE STUDENTS SPEAKING SKILLS 

Journal : 

Research journal and learning innovation

Volume and Page :

Vol. 1 Number 2, August 2021, page 144 - 152 

 

Publicated year :

2021

Writer :

1) Ayu Octavianita

2) Kiki Wahyuni

3) Suryadi Amdhan Nur

4) Tuti Handayani 

5) Muhammad Taufik Ihsan 

Reviewer :

Dhea Fitri Ayuningtyas (2010631060066)

Date :

2 Maret 2022

The aim of research :

The goal of this study is to find out how instructors employ the Communicative Language Teaching approach in the English classroom, as well as the strategies and resources they use to help students develop their speaking skills

The subject of research :

focuses mostly on other journals and publications to generate the arguments in this article.

The assesment data :

Document studies are used to assess the strategies in CLT

Methodology of research :

This journal takes the form of a review of documents and literatures, with an evaluation of knowledge as the basis. All articles regarding CLT may be found on the internet. In addition, a review of classroom exercises and speaking material is conducted. Articles and online news provide access to all important linked materials. 

Discussion :

The goal of this study is to find out how instructors employ the Communicative Language Teaching approach in the English classroom, as well as the strategies and resources they use to help students develop their speaking skills.This can be seen from the class activities, speaking materials until the strategies that has been implemented in some research. This article takes the form of a review of documents and literatures, with an evaluation of knowledge as the basis. As a result, as a teacher, you may learn from other countries that have successfully implemented and developed CLT in improving students' speaking skills. 

Conclusion

According to the author, communicative competence encompasses the following aspects of language knowledge: knowing how to use the language in various situations, knowing how to vary the use of the language according to settings and participants (formal and informal speech), being able to understand various types of texts, and so on. When utilizing communicative activities in the classroom, a difference should be made between fluency and accuracy, with fluency being defined as the natural language usage that occurs when speakers participate in a discussion despite their communicative competence limitations. On the other hand, accuracy refers to the development of accurate examples of language usage. 

The advantages of research in this journal

The advantages presented by the authors in this journal are that the findings of this study clearly show that authentic language contexts allow students to practice all the principles they have learned in class; Also, trying to use English on their own will definitely be an example of a native language application they will use when appearing as professionals.

Disadvantages of research in this journal

The shortcomings encountered by the authors in the research on the application of the CLT approach to speaking comprehension are that due to differences in English level, it is sometimes difficult to classify students; one possible solution is to give students a placement test so that they can be grouped homogeneously later. Another problem with large groups is that it is difficult for teachers to track their students' progress in communicative exercises.

Journal Source :

https://doi.org/10.51574/jrip.v1i2.42